Back to Articles
Linguistics
Research Article
Open Access

Cultivating Effective Reading Habits in Higher Education: Challenges and Pathways to English Language Proficiency

NR
NUR ANNISA ROSLANOR
Akademi Pengajian Bahasa (APB), Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM), Shah Alam, SelangorMalaysia
AN
ALEYSHA ADRIANA SHAHRIL NIZAM
Akademi Pengajian Bahasa (APB), Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM), Shah Alam, SelangorMalaysia
NZ
NUR ARISYAZALIA MOHD ZALWI
Akademi Pengajian Bahasa (APB), Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM), Shah Alam, SelangorMalaysia
HM
HAIRUL AZHAR MOHAMAD
Akademi Pengajian Bahasa (APB), Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM), Shah Alam, SelangorMalaysia
MR
MUHAMMAD HAZIQ ABD RASHID*ORCID
Akademi Pengajian Bahasa (APB), Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM), Shah Alam, SelangorMalaysia

* Corresponding author

Abstract

Reading plays a fundamental role in the development of English language proficiency by enhancing vocabulary acquisition, grammatical knowledge, comprehension abilities, and critical thinking skills. Despite its importance, many university students encounter persistent challenges that hinder the development of effective reading habits and limit opportunities for meaningful language growth. This paper examines the major barriers affecting reading development among university students and explores how these challenges influence English language proficiency. Guided by Reading Engagement Theory and Self-Determination Theory, the discussion is organised around four interconnected dimensions: cognitive and affective barriers to reading development, reading culture and literacy support, literacy competence and advanced reading challenges, and pedagogical practices influencing reading engagement. The analysis suggests that reading anxiety, limited intrinsic motivation, dependence on extrinsic incentives, inadequate literacy support, vocabulary limitations, weak critical reading skills, and traditional instructional approaches collectively restrict students’ reading development. Furthermore, excessive reliance on passive learning strategies and fragmented vocabulary instruction may impede learners’ ability to engage deeply with texts and develop higher-order comprehension skills. The paper argues that successful reading development requires more than exposure to texts alone; it demands supportive learning environments, meaningful reading experiences, learner autonomy, and instructional approaches that promote active engagement. Strengthening reading culture, expanding opportunities for extensive reading, and fostering intrinsic motivation may contribute significantly to improved language proficiency and academic achievement. Future research should explore digital reading environments, reading engagement in multilingual contexts, technology-assisted literacy development, and the long-term effects of reading habits on language learning outcomes.

Keywords: Reading habits; Reading anxiety; Reading engagement; English Language Proficiency; Literacy Development; Vocabulary Acquisition

1 Introduction#

Reading has long been recognised as one of the most influential contributors to language acquisition and academic development. Through reading, students are exposed to new vocabulary, grammatical structures, discourse patterns, and diverse forms of written communication that collectively strengthen English language proficiency. Beyond linguistic development, reading supports critical thinking, analytical reasoning, and knowledge construction, making it a fundamental component of success in higher education. Students who engage regularly with reading materials generally demonstrate stronger comprehension skills, broader vocabulary knowledge, and greater confidence when communicating in English. Consequently, reading serves not only as a language-learning activity but also as a means of fostering intellectual growth and lifelong learning habits (Khusniyah & Ariawan, 2024; Ali et al., 2023).

Despite the recognised importance of reading, many university students struggle to establish consistent reading habits and encounter significant obstacles that hinder their literacy development. These challenges extend beyond basic decoding skills and often include reading anxiety, comprehension difficulties, limited motivation, insufficient vocabulary knowledge, and weak engagement with academic texts. Furthermore, the increasing presence of digital distractions, including social media and entertainment platforms, has changed students' reading behaviours by competing for their attention and reducing the amount of time devoted to sustained reading practices. As a result, many learners view reading as a task required for examinations and coursework rather than as a meaningful process of knowledge acquisition and language development (Affendi & Noah, 2022; Oh et al., 2022).

To better understand these challenges, this paper draws upon Reading Engagement Theory and Self-Determination Theory as complementary theoretical perspectives. Reading Engagement Theory emphasizes the importance of active participation, motivation, and meaningful interaction with texts in promoting literacy development and reading achievement. Meanwhile, Self-Determination Theory highlights the distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, arguing that learners are more likely to sustain educational behaviours when activities satisfy their needs for autonomy, competence, and personal relevance. Together, these frameworks provide a useful lens for understanding why some students develop strong reading habits while others struggle to engage consistently with reading materials. They also help explain how cognitive, motivational, environmental, and instructional factors influence reading behaviour and literacy outcomes (Deci & Ryan, 2000; Khusniyah & Ariawan, 2024).

The discussion is organised around four interconnected dimensions that influence reading development among university students: cognitive and affective barriers to reading development, reading culture and home literacy support, literacy competence and advanced reading challenges, and pedagogical practices that shape reading engagement. By examining these dimensions collectively, the paper argues that reading difficulties are not simply the result of individual learner weaknesses but emerge from the interaction of motivational, cognitive, social, and instructional factors. Understanding these relationships is essential for developing more effective approaches to reading instruction and creating educational environments that encourage sustained reading engagement, stronger literacy development, and improved English language proficiency among university students.

2 Cognitive and Affective Barriers to Reading Development#

Reading development among university students is influenced not only by linguistic ability but also by a range of cognitive and affective factors that shape learners’ engagement with reading activities. Successful reading requires the ability to process information, interpret meaning, make inferences, and sustain attention throughout increasingly complex texts. However, many students encounter psychological barriers that interfere with these processes, reducing both reading effectiveness and enjoyment. Among the most frequently reported obstacles are reading anxiety, low confidence in comprehension abilities, weak intrinsic motivation, and excessive dependence on external rewards for engagement. These factors significantly affect students’ willingness to read regularly and ultimately influence the development of English language proficiency (Affendi & Noah, 2022; Ali et al., 2023).

One of the most prominent affective barriers is reading anxiety, which refers to the tension, apprehension, or fear students experience when engaging with English-language texts. Reading anxiety often emerges when learners encounter unfamiliar vocabulary, complex grammatical structures, or dense academic passages that exceed their perceived language proficiency. According to Affendi and Noah (2022), low-proficiency learners frequently struggle with vocabulary limitations, insufficient grammatical knowledge, and difficulties understanding textual organisation, all of which contribute to reduced reading confidence. Similarly, Edward et al. (2021) observed that many Malaysian ESL learners experience considerable difficulty comprehending English texts, particularly when academic reading demands exceed their current language competence. As learners repeatedly encounter texts they perceive as difficult, anxiety can increase and gradually discourage sustained engagement with reading activities. Consequently, reading anxiety often becomes a self-reinforcing barrier that limits opportunities for language growth and literacy development.

The cognitive consequences of reading anxiety extend beyond emotional discomfort and directly affect comprehension performance. Students experiencing anxiety frequently devote substantial mental resources to worrying about understanding a text rather than focusing on its meaning. As a result, cognitive processing becomes less efficient, reducing learners’ ability to identify key ideas, recognise relationships between concepts, and construct coherent interpretations of texts. Research in second-language reading suggests that anxious readers tend to engage in excessive monitoring of individual words and phrases rather than processing information holistically. This tendency slows reading speed and increases cognitive load, making comprehension more difficult and reducing overall reading fluency. Such findings indicate that addressing reading anxiety is essential not only for emotional well-being but also for improving the cognitive processes that support effective reading comprehension.

Motivation represents another critical factor influencing reading development. Students who possess strong intrinsic motivation are more likely to engage voluntarily with reading materials because they perceive reading as meaningful, enjoyable, and personally relevant. However, many learners demonstrate limited intrinsic interest in reading and instead view it primarily as an academic requirement. According to Ali, Raza, Yasmeen, Raza, and Munawar (2023), students’ reading habits are closely associated with academic performance, yet many learners fail to develop sustained reading practices because reading is often linked solely to examinations and coursework. When reading becomes a task rather than a source of intellectual curiosity, learners are less likely to engage deeply with texts or develop long-term reading habits. Consequently, the absence of intrinsic motivation may significantly reduce opportunities for language learning and literacy growth.

Closely related to low intrinsic motivation is students’ reliance on extrinsic motivators. Many university students read primarily to complete assignments, pass examinations, or fulfil academic expectations rather than to acquire knowledge or expand language proficiency. Although external incentives can encourage short-term engagement, they rarely foster sustainable reading behaviours. Self-Determination Theory suggests that learning activities are more likely to be maintained over time when they satisfy learners’ needs for autonomy, competence, and personal relevance. Students motivated solely by grades or assessment requirements often disengage from reading once immediate academic demands have been met. As a result, reading becomes sporadic and transactional rather than a consistent developmental practice. This pattern limits opportunities for extensive reading, vocabulary growth, and the gradual accumulation of literacy-related knowledge that contributes to long-term language development (Deci & Ryan, 2000; Ali et al., 2023).

Another important cognitive challenge involves the tendency of struggling readers to adopt compensatory strategies that provide short-term assistance but may hinder long-term reading development. Students experiencing low confidence frequently rely on repeated reading, word-for-word translation, and frequent dictionary consultation in an attempt to overcome comprehension difficulties. While these strategies can sometimes improve immediate understanding, excessive reliance on them disrupts reading flow and prevents learners from developing more efficient comprehension strategies. According to Affendi and Noah (2022), low-proficiency readers often engage in repeated reading and self-monitoring because they lack confidence in their ability to understand texts independently. Over time, this behaviour may create dependence on external support rather than encouraging the development of inferencing skills and autonomous reading strategies. Consequently, confidence-building interventions are essential for helping learners become more independent and proficient readers.

These findings indicate that cognitive and affective barriers constitute significant obstacles to reading development among university students. Reading anxiety, low confidence, limited intrinsic motivation, dependence on extrinsic rewards, and ineffective reading strategies collectively influence how students engage with texts and develop literacy skills. Importantly, these challenges are interconnected rather than independent. Anxiety can weaken motivation, limited motivation can reduce reading practice, and reduced practice can further undermine confidence and comprehension. Addressing these barriers therefore requires educational approaches that promote positive reading experiences, support learner autonomy, strengthen reading self-efficacy, and create opportunities for meaningful engagement with texts. By fostering both cognitive competence and emotional resilience, educators can help students develop stronger reading habits and improve overall English language proficiency.

3 Reading Culture, Personal Interest, and Home Literacy Support#

The development of strong reading habits is influenced not only by individual reading ability but also by the broader literacy culture surrounding learners. Reading culture refers to the values, attitudes, behaviours, and environmental conditions that encourage individuals to engage regularly with reading activities. University students who develop positive reading habits are more likely to view reading as a meaningful and rewarding activity rather than merely an academic requirement. However, many learners struggle to cultivate sustainable reading practices because reading competes with alternative forms of entertainment and digital engagement. Consequently, the development of reading proficiency is often constrained not by a lack of access to reading materials alone but by the absence of a supportive reading culture that encourages consistent engagement with texts. Research consistently demonstrates that students with stronger reading habits tend to exhibit higher levels of academic achievement, better comprehension skills, and greater English language proficiency (Khusniyah & Ariawan, 2024; Ali et al., 2023).

One important factor contributing to weak reading habits among university students is low personal interest in reading. Students who do not perceive reading as enjoyable or personally relevant are less likely to engage voluntarily with texts outside compulsory academic tasks. Reading then becomes associated primarily with examinations, assignments, and institutional obligations rather than intellectual exploration or personal enrichment. According to Ali, Raza, Yasmeen, Raza, and Munawar (2023), students' reading habits are strongly connected to academic performance because consistent reading promotes vocabulary growth, content knowledge, and critical-thinking abilities. However, when personal interest is lacking, learners often devote minimal time to reading activities, thereby reducing opportunities for literacy development and language acquisition. This suggests that fostering reading interest should be viewed as a central objective of language education rather than merely a supplementary concern.

The home environment also plays a critical role in shaping reading attitudes and behaviours. Numerous studies have demonstrated that students who are exposed to books, reading materials, and literacy-related activities from an early age are more likely to develop positive reading habits. Family members who encourage reading, discuss books, and provide access to literacy resources contribute significantly to the development of reading confidence and motivation. In contrast, students who receive limited literacy support at home may have fewer opportunities to engage with reading outside educational settings. Khusniyah and Ariawan (2024) emphasise that sustainable reading habits are strengthened when learners are consistently exposed to reading activities in supportive environments. Therefore, home literacy practices represent an important foundation for long-term reading engagement and language development.

The influence of home literacy support extends beyond access to reading materials and includes the attitudes families hold toward reading and education. Students are more likely to value reading when parents or caregivers model positive reading behaviours and demonstrate that literacy serves meaningful purposes beyond academic assessment. When reading is viewed as a normal and enjoyable part of daily life, learners are more likely to internalise positive attitudes toward literacy. Conversely, limited exposure to reading role models may contribute to the perception that reading is solely a school-related activity with little relevance beyond formal education. These attitudes often affect learners' willingness to engage with lengthy or challenging texts, especially in a second language. Consequently, strengthening literacy cultures within families and communities may significantly enhance students' reading engagement and educational outcomes.

Another important issue concerns the growing influence of digital media on reading behaviour. Contemporary university students spend considerable time engaging with social media, short-form digital content, and online entertainment platforms that may reduce opportunities for sustained reading. While digital technologies provide access to vast amounts of information, they may also encourage fragmented attention and superficial information consumption. Research on reading habits suggests that extensive engagement with digital distractions can interfere with the development of deep reading practices that support comprehension and critical thinking (Oh et al., 2022). As learners become accustomed to brief and rapidly changing content, they may find it increasingly difficult to engage with longer academic texts that require concentration and sustained cognitive effort. This shift highlights the need to promote balanced digital habits that support rather than undermine literacy development.

Reading culture is also influenced by students' perceptions of the purpose and value of reading. Learners who recognise reading as a tool for personal growth, professional development, and intellectual exploration are more likely to engage consistently with texts. Reading provides opportunities not only to acquire language knowledge but also to develop analytical reasoning, empathy, cultural awareness, and independent learning skills. However, when educational systems focus primarily on assessment outcomes, students may develop instrumental attitudes toward reading that limit opportunities for deeper engagement. Encouraging learners to select reading materials aligned with their interests, goals, and experiences may help strengthen intrinsic motivation and support lifelong literacy development. Such approaches align with contemporary educational perspectives that emphasize learner autonomy and meaningful engagement rather than compliance-based reading practices.

Taken together, these findings demonstrate that reading development is profoundly shaped by cultural, social, and environmental influences. Low personal interest, limited home literacy support, weak reading cultures, and increasing digital distractions all contribute to reduced engagement with reading activities. Yet these challenges also highlight opportunities for intervention. By fostering positive reading attitudes, strengthening home and institutional literacy support, promoting learner autonomy, and creating environments that encourage meaningful engagement with texts, educators can help students develop stronger reading habits and improve their English language proficiency. Ultimately, cultivating a sustainable reading culture represents one of the most effective long-term strategies for supporting literacy development and academic success among university students.

4 Literacy Competence and Advanced Reading Challenges#

Literacy competence represents a fundamental component of successful reading development because it enables learners to interpret, analyse, evaluate, and respond critically to written texts. In higher education, reading extends beyond recognising vocabulary and understanding individual sentences; students are expected to engage with complex academic materials, identify key arguments, evaluate evidence, and construct informed interpretations. However, many university students encounter difficulties when attempting to navigate texts that require higher-order reading skills. These challenges often emerge from weaknesses in basic literacy competencies, limited reading fluency, restricted vocabulary knowledge, and insufficient exposure to advanced reading tasks. As a result, students may struggle to comprehend academic texts effectively, hindering both language development and overall academic performance (Khusniyah & Ariawan, 2024; Edward et al., 2022).

One of the most common literacy-related challenges involves difficulty identifying main ideas and supporting details within a text. Effective reading requires learners to distinguish central arguments from supplementary information while recognising how different parts of a text contribute to overall meaning. Students who lack this ability frequently experience comprehension problems because they focus on isolated details without understanding how those details relate to broader themes and concepts. According to Khusniyah and Ariawan (2024), many learners continue to operate at basic levels of reading comprehension where understanding remains limited to surface-level information. Such difficulties can significantly affect academic achievement because students are unable to extract essential information efficiently from reading materials. Consequently, the development of foundational literacy skills remains a critical prerequisite for more advanced forms of reading comprehension.

Beyond identifying key information, many students also struggle with inferential and analytical reading processes. Academic reading frequently requires learners to interpret implied meanings, evaluate arguments, identify assumptions, and synthesise information from multiple sources. These tasks demand cognitive engagement beyond literal comprehension and require readers to interact actively with textual content. Research indicates that students who lack inferential reading skills often encounter difficulties when responding to comprehension questions, summarising texts, or evaluating the validity of arguments presented by authors. Such challenges become increasingly significant at university level where students are expected to engage critically with academic literature and demonstrate higher-order thinking abilities. Therefore, literacy competence should be understood not merely as the ability to decode information but also as the capacity to analyse and interpret complex texts effectively (Khusniyah & Ariawan, 2024).

Another major challenge relates to the increasing complexity of academic reading materials encountered in higher education. University students are regularly exposed to specialised vocabulary, sophisticated sentence structures, abstract concepts, and discipline-specific discourse conventions that differ considerably from the texts encountered in earlier stages of education. According to Edward et al. (2022), many ESL undergraduates report enjoying English reading activities but continue to experience difficulties when working with complex academic texts. Such difficulties often arise because learners lack exposure to advanced reading materials or have not developed the strategies necessary to process challenging linguistic content efficiently. Consequently, students may become overwhelmed by technical terminology and complex textual organisation, reducing confidence and weakening motivation to engage with academic reading tasks.

Vocabulary knowledge plays an equally significant role in determining reading success. Students with limited vocabulary frequently struggle to understand key concepts because unfamiliar words disrupt comprehension and interrupt reading fluency. This challenge becomes particularly problematic when academic texts contain specialised terminology or when contextual clues are insufficient for inferring meaning independently. According to Al Roomy (2022), frequent encounters with unfamiliar vocabulary often generate frustration and anxiety while simultaneously increasing learners’ dependence on dictionaries and translation tools. Excessive reliance on these supports may slow reading speed and reduce opportunities to develop inferencing skills that are essential for independent reading. Furthermore, limited vocabulary knowledge restricts learners’ ability to comprehend texts holistically because cognitive resources are redirected toward decoding individual lexical items rather than constructing broader textual meaning.

Recent scholarship has emphasised the importance of developing higher-order reading strategies to address these challenges. Skilled readers actively monitor comprehension, infer meaning from context, connect ideas across texts, and evaluate information critically rather than focusing exclusively on individual words or sentences. Such strategies allow learners to process information more efficiently while developing independence as readers. Research by Al Roomy (2022) demonstrates that readers who employ vocabulary-learning strategies within contextualised reading activities are more successful in inferring meanings and retaining new lexical knowledge. Similarly, sustained engagement with authentic texts encourages vocabulary growth, improves reading fluency, and strengthens comprehension over time. These findings suggest that literacy development is most effective when learners are encouraged to engage with texts holistically and apply strategic reading behaviours rather than relying solely on mechanical decoding processes.

Taken together, these findings indicate that literacy competence and advanced reading skills represent essential foundations for English language development among university students. Difficulties involving identification of main ideas, inferential comprehension, academic text processing, and vocabulary knowledge all contribute to weaker reading performance and reduced reading confidence. Importantly, these challenges are interconnected because weaknesses in one area often affect performance in others. Addressing such issues therefore requires comprehensive instructional approaches that strengthen foundational literacy skills while simultaneously developing higher-order comprehension strategies, vocabulary depth, and critical reading abilities. By supporting students’ progression from basic comprehension toward more sophisticated forms of literacy engagement, educational institutions can enhance both academic success and long-term English language proficiency.

5 Pedagogical Practices and Student Engagement in Reading Instruction#

Pedagogical practices play a central role in shaping students’ reading experiences, engagement, and overall literacy development. While reading proficiency depends on learners’ cognitive abilities and motivation, instructional approaches significantly influence how students interact with texts and develop long-term reading habits. Effective reading instruction should encourage active engagement, critical reflection, and meaningful interaction with reading materials. However, many educational environments continue to rely heavily on traditional approaches that prioritise memorisation, isolated vocabulary learning, and repetitive exercises over authentic engagement with complete texts. As a result, students may perceive reading as a mechanical academic task rather than a meaningful process of language development and knowledge construction. Contemporary scholarship increasingly suggests that instructional practices should move beyond passive transmission of information and instead create opportunities for students to participate actively in reading activities that promote comprehension, reflection, and independent learning (Schmidtke et al., 2024; Elvriza & Nurcholis, 2025).

One significant limitation of traditional reading instruction is its tendency to focus on isolated vocabulary memorisation rather than contextualised language learning. Students are often required to learn long lists of individual words without sufficient exposure to how those words function within authentic texts. While vocabulary acquisition remains important, learning words in isolation may not adequately prepare students to comprehend real academic or literary materials. According to Schmidtke, Rahmanian, and Moro (2024), reading fluency is closely associated with sustained exposure to continuous texts rather than repetitive vocabulary drills. Learners who regularly engage with extensive reading activities encounter words repeatedly in meaningful contexts, allowing vocabulary knowledge to develop naturally through usage and repetition. Consequently, instructional approaches that emphasise contextualised reading may be more effective than traditional memorisation-based methods in supporting long-term language development.

Another challenge lies in the prevalence of passive classroom environments that limit meaningful interaction with texts. In many instructional settings, reading activities are reduced to answering comprehension questions, translating passages, or identifying isolated linguistic features. Such approaches often encourage students to focus on surface-level understanding rather than deeper interpretation and critical engagement. Elvriza and Nurcholis (2025) argue that low-engagement reading environments frequently diminish learners’ motivation because reading becomes disconnected from authentic communication and personal meaning. When students are positioned primarily as passive recipients of information, opportunities for discussion, interpretation, and collaborative learning are reduced. Consequently, learners may become less invested in reading activities and struggle to recognise the broader educational value of literacy development.

Student choice and autonomy represent important factors in promoting meaningful engagement with reading. Research increasingly demonstrates that learners are more motivated when they are able to select reading materials that align with their interests, experiences, and learning objectives. Opportunities for independent reading and peer discussion encourage students to become active participants in the learning process rather than passive consumers of information. According to Elvriza and Nurcholis (2025), students who are permitted to choose novels and engage in collaborative reading discussions often demonstrate measurable improvements in vocabulary knowledge and reading engagement. Such findings are consistent with Self-Determination Theory, which emphasises the importance of autonomy in fostering intrinsic motivation. Therefore, instructional practices that support learner choice may significantly strengthen reading habits and contribute to greater language proficiency.

The issue of incidental vocabulary acquisition further illustrates the importance of active reading instruction. Incidental vocabulary acquisition occurs when learners acquire new words naturally through exposure to meaningful language rather than through direct vocabulary instruction. Many students experience difficulties developing vocabulary because they focus excessively on individual words and rely heavily on dictionaries and translation strategies. According to Al Roomy (2022), readers who adopt holistic reading strategies and utilise contextual clues are more successful in inferring meaning and retaining new lexical knowledge. Exposure to complete texts enables learners to encounter vocabulary repeatedly across different contexts, supporting deeper understanding and long-term retention. Consequently, instructional approaches that promote extensive reading and contextual learning create more favourable conditions for vocabulary growth than methods centred primarily on isolated vocabulary exercises.

Recent developments in technology and digital reading environments have also influenced pedagogical approaches to reading instruction. Smartphones, e-books, online articles, and digital learning platforms provide learners with unprecedented access to reading materials. However, effective integration of these technologies requires careful instructional design to ensure that digital reading promotes deep engagement rather than superficial information consumption. Oh, Krish, and Hamat (2022) observe that students increasingly use smartphones as reading tools, creating new opportunities for literacy development as well as new challenges related to concentration and sustained engagement. Educators must therefore consider how digital reading practices can be combined with active learning strategies to maximise comprehension and maintain learner motivation. This highlights the need for flexible pedagogical approaches that respond to the changing nature of reading in contemporary educational environments.

Taken together, these findings demonstrate that pedagogical practices exert substantial influence on students’ reading development and engagement with English language texts. Traditional instructional approaches that rely heavily on memorisation, passive learning, and isolated vocabulary exercises may limit learners’ ability to develop meaningful reading habits and higher-order literacy skills. In contrast, instructional environments that emphasise extensive reading, contextual vocabulary acquisition, learner autonomy, collaborative discussion, and active engagement are more likely to promote sustained literacy development and language growth. Enhancing reading proficiency therefore requires not only motivated learners but also pedagogical practices that position reading as an interactive, purposeful, and intellectually engaging activity. By creating classrooms that encourage active participation and authentic engagement with texts, educators can support students in becoming confident, independent, and proficient readers of English.

6 Discussion and Conclusion#

The discussion presented throughout this paper demonstrates that the challenges associated with reading development among university students are multidimensional and deeply interconnected. Reading proficiency cannot be understood solely as a linguistic skill because successful reading requires the integration of cognitive, motivational, social, and instructional factors. The analysis reveals that students frequently encounter reading barriers arising from anxiety, limited motivation, weak literacy foundations, and ineffective instructional environments. These challenges often operate simultaneously, creating a cumulative effect that influences both reading engagement and English language development. Consequently, reading difficulties should be viewed not as isolated learner deficiencies but as outcomes shaped by broader educational, personal, and contextual influences.

One of the most significant findings emerging from this discussion is the reciprocal relationship between cognitive and affective factors in reading development. Students who experience reading anxiety often struggle with comprehension and become less confident in their reading abilities; reduced confidence then discourages continued engagement with reading activities. Similarly, insufficient motivation weakens reading habits, resulting in less exposure to language and consequently slower literacy development. This cyclical relationship highlights the importance of fostering positive reading experiences that strengthen both comprehension and confidence. Reading engagement theory suggests that students are more likely to persist with reading when they perceive it as meaningful, relevant, and personally rewarding. Therefore, efforts to improve reading proficiency must address emotional and motivational dimensions alongside cognitive skills.

The discussion also highlights the crucial role of reading culture and literacy support in shaping students’ long-term reading behaviour. Reading habits are rarely developed in isolation; rather, they emerge through interactions with families, educational institutions, peers, and wider social environments. Students who are exposed to supportive literacy environments tend to develop stronger reading identities and are more likely to engage voluntarily with texts. Conversely, weak reading cultures and limited literacy support may contribute to disengagement and reduced reading frequency. These observations indicate that universities should promote literacy-rich environments that encourage reading not only for academic purposes but also for personal growth, intellectual exploration, and lifelong learning. Strengthening reading culture therefore represents a key strategy for supporting sustainable literacy development among university students.

Another important theme concerns the relationship between literacy competence and academic success. The ability to identify main ideas, evaluate arguments, infer meaning, and interpret complex texts is essential for effective participation in higher education. However, many students continue to struggle with advanced reading tasks because of vocabulary limitations, weak inferential skills, and insufficient experience with academic texts. These difficulties restrict learners’ ability to engage critically with content and may negatively affect performance across multiple disciplines. Consequently, literacy development should be viewed as a continuing process that requires deliberate instructional support throughout university education. Strengthening literacy competence enables learners not only to comprehend information more effectively but also to participate more actively in academic discourse and critical inquiry.

The discussion further demonstrates that pedagogical practices exert a substantial influence on students’ reading engagement and literacy development. Traditional instructional methods that rely heavily on memorisation, isolated vocabulary drills, and passive classroom participation may inadvertently discourage meaningful engagement with texts. In contrast, instructional approaches that promote extensive reading, learner autonomy, collaborative discussion, and contextualised vocabulary learning encourage deeper interaction with reading materials. Active learning environments support the development of higher-order thinking skills while helping students view reading as a purposeful and intellectually stimulating activity. These findings suggest that educators play a pivotal role in shaping students’ reading experiences by designing learning environments that encourage curiosity, reflection, and sustained literacy engagement.

In conclusion, reading development is a complex process influenced by cognitive, motivational, literacy, and pedagogical factors that work together to shape students’ English language proficiency. Reading anxiety, low motivation, weak literacy competence, limited reading culture, and ineffective teaching practices all contribute to the challenges experienced by university students. However, these challenges are not insurmountable. By fostering supportive literacy environments, encouraging intrinsic motivation, strengthening higher-order reading skills, and adopting student-centred instructional approaches, educational institutions can help learners develop stronger reading habits and greater confidence in their abilities. Ultimately, improving reading engagement represents one of the most effective ways to enhance language proficiency, academic achievement, and lifelong learning among university students.

7 Future Research Recommendations#

Future research should investigate the influence of digital reading environments on literacy development among university students. The increasing use of smartphones, e-books, online journals, and artificial intelligence-supported reading tools has transformed the way learners interact with texts. While digital platforms offer greater accessibility and convenience, limited evidence exists regarding their long-term impact on reading comprehension, vocabulary acquisition, and critical reading performance. Longitudinal studies examining how students engage with digital resources over time may provide valuable insights into the relationship between technology use and literacy development. Such research could help educators design more effective digital reading strategies that support deep engagement rather than superficial information consumption.

Another important area for future research concerns the development of reading motivation in multilingual educational contexts. Many university students study English as a second or foreign language while simultaneously operating within multilingual environments that influence reading behaviour and literacy practices. Investigating how linguistic diversity affects reading habits, motivation, and comprehension may contribute to a stronger understanding of reading development among multilingual learners. Future studies could explore how identity, language preferences, and sociocultural experiences influence students’ willingness to engage with English-language texts. Such findings would help educators develop more inclusive literacy programmes that reflect the realities of multilingual learning environments.

Future investigations should also examine the effectiveness of extensive reading programmes in promoting long-term literacy development. Although numerous studies indicate positive relationships between extensive reading and language growth, additional research is needed to determine which programme designs produce the strongest outcomes across different educational settings. Comparative studies involving various reading interventions, digital platforms, and instructional approaches may reveal more effective strategies for fostering reading engagement among university students. Moreover, identifying factors that encourage students to maintain reading habits beyond formal coursework would provide valuable guidance for literacy development initiatives.

An additional research direction involves exploring the relationship between reading engagement and academic resilience. Students who struggle with reading frequently encounter challenges that affect confidence, motivation, and academic performance. Understanding how learners overcome these challenges and persist despite difficulties may contribute to the development of interventions that strengthen both literacy skills and academic self-efficacy. Research examining psychological resilience, reading confidence, and learner autonomy could provide deeper insight into the factors that support successful reading development over time. Such findings would be particularly valuable in identifying strategies that help struggling readers become more independent and confident learners.

Finally, future studies should investigate the role of educators in cultivating sustainable reading cultures within higher education. While substantial attention has been given to student-centred factors, less research has examined how institutional policies, classroom practices, and literacy promotion initiatives influence reading engagement. Comparative studies across universities and educational systems may reveal effective practices that support reading culture development and literacy growth. Understanding how educators, institutions, and communities contribute to reading engagement would strengthen efforts to create environments where reading becomes a meaningful and enduring component of students’ academic and personal lives. Ultimately, continued research in these areas will contribute to more comprehensive and effective approaches for improving reading proficiency and English language development in higher education.

Declarations

Funding. This research received no external funding.

Conflict of interest. The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Affendi, F. R., & Noah, J. B. (2022). English language reading strategies: Low proficiency adult learners in a Malaysian university. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 12(4), 1496–1507. https://doi.org/10.6007/IJARBSS/v12-i4/13056
  2. Ali, I., Raza, M. H., Yasmeen, M., Raza, M. A., & Munawar, N. (2023). Analyzing the impact of students’ reading habits on academic performance. International Journal of Scientific Multidisciplinary Research, 1(8), 951–962. https://doi.org/10.55927/ijsmr.v1i8.5886
  3. Al Roomy, M. A. (2022). Investigating the effects of critical reading skills on students’ reading comprehension. Arab World English Journal, 13(1), 366–381. https://doi.org/10.24093/awej/vol13no1.24
  4. Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). The “what” and “why” of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268. https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327965PLI1104_01
  5. Edward, E. I., Kamlun, K., Din, W. A., & Pudin, C. S. J. (2021). Reading difficulties among Malaysian undergraduate ESL learners: A preliminary study. International Journal of Education, Psychology and Counseling, 6(43), 62–70. https://doi.org/10.35631/IJEPC.643006
  6. Edward, E. I., Kamlun, K., Din, W. A., & Pudin, C. S. J. (2022). ESL undergraduates’ reading habits and attitudes towards English language reading. International Journal of Education, Psychology and Counselling, 7(48), 291–300. https://doi.org/10.35631/IJEPC.748021
  7. Elvriza, M. S., & Nurcholis, I. A. (2025). The impact of extensive reading of novels on students’ English vocabulary acquisition. Indonesian Journal of Education, 1(3), 94–102. https://doi.org/10.71417/ije.v1i3.215
  8. Khusniyah, N. L., & Ariawan, S. (2024). Enhancing English reading proficiency through student reading habits. Al-Ishlah: Jurnal Pendidikan, 16(2), 1816–1824. https://doi.org/10.35445/alishlah.v16i2.4760
  9. Oh, C. M., Krish, P., & Hamat, A. (2024). Reading on smartphones: Students’ habits and implications for reading skills. Computer Assisted Language Learning Electronic Journal, 23(1), 259–277.
  10. Schmidtke, J., Rahmanian, S., & Moro, A. L. (2024). Reading experience drives L2 reading speed development: a longitudinal study of EAL reading habits. Frontiers in Education, 9, Article 1286132. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2024.1286132

Cite This Article

Roslanor, N. A., Shahril Nizam, A. A., Mohd Zalwi, N. A., Mohamad, H. A., & Abd Rashid, M. H. (2026). Cultivating effective reading habits in higher education: Challenges and pathways to english language proficiency. Hanford Scholars - Journal of Social Sciences & Humanities, 1(1), 13–24. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24340404